Star Trekkin’ (Again?)

It looks like lapsed subs can now get back into Star Trek Online, in advance of the game’s full F2P re-launch on the 17th. I played the game when it first came out and have considered going back a few times, based on recommendations from friends and former co-workers. I liked it, to a degree (the space battles were especially fun, at least when I could point my ship in the right direction), but my major issue with the game was the voluminous level of maintenance required to keep apace with things.

Set phasers to "Exterminate"

Unlike some people who found the game’s missions and overall style of play repetitive, I left the game because of there being too many little details that required my constant attention. I like to think I’m a fairly meticulous person who’s not overly bothered by a lot of detail in my games. But STO overloaded me, I felt, with too much to keep track of, too early. In addition to my main character, I had to maintain four bridge crew officers, complete with their own equipment, weapons (each with multiple settings), and (poorly described) skill sets, not to mention my ship with all its potential modifications. When I tried to “take it easy” for a while and not micromanage my crew, we would invariably get torn to pieces by a group of Klingons. Toss in that I was an engineer, and so would want to set up as many fortifications — mines, turrets, and force shields — before an encounter, which necessitated changing my tool kit, and the bewildering array of ship components, vendor trash, crafting materials, and other detritus that clogged up my inventory, and the game became almost untenable, even at level 11 — er, Lieutenant Commander, 2nd class (or whatever it was) — before I just packed it in.

Sure, they look cute...

This aspect of the game seemed to me to be the biggest reason why the game fell flat in many people’s eyes. When you make a game based on a well-known and popular license such as Star Trek, it’s a mistake to go overboard with minutia because, geeky as your fan base is, a fair number of them are going to be dipping their toes into this genre for the first time, since they’re fans of the license first and MMORPGs second (if at all — when I did the SWTOR demo at PAX East, one of the people in my foursome confessed to never having played an MMO). It’s easy to think that everyone shares your devotion, your passion, and your drive to play a game based on your favorite property, but some people just want to jump into the shoes and ripped shirt of Captain Kirk and not have to wonder if they’ve got the right secondary weapon setting for their security officer’s Type II Phaser Rifle. We can poke fun at games like SWTOR and The Lord of the Rings Online for being fairly basic WoW-clone-ish games, but the WoW formula works for the masses and is probably the best choice for games meant to appeal to a large, mass-market audience. Save the innovations and big changes to the genre for the likes of Guild Wars 2 and The Secret World.

Anyway, I probably will hop back into my Andorian engineer for at least a little while, just to see how the game’s changed and to at least slightly refamiliarize myself with the controls. I’ve been away for so long that my ship’s probably overrun by tribbles by this point, though…

Advertisements
This entry was posted in MMOs, Video Games and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Star Trekkin’ (Again?)

  1. dndhatcher says:

    Figures you would be Andorian…

    I wonder if my open beta account will let me into the game early. It works on the website so there is hope…

    • Eric says:

      As long as you bought a subscription at any time, you can play it. Excluding that “demo” subscription when they had the demo.

      Despite only tutorials and highly restricted content in the demo, I found the graphics to be magnificent. Though taking it form their Champions, it’s got its unique quirks and systems unlike any I’ve seen yet.

  2. I only played ST:O for a day, but I didn’t much like it. Largely for the reasons you state; it was much too much complication. That and some interface quirks that drove me crazy. And too many load screens. Ugh, so many load screens.

    The only thing I liked about it was how much customization there was for ships and characters. Much like Rift’s marksman class, the ability to pick your toon’s body language is the one redeeming feature of an otherwise dull game that I am now doomed to spend the rest of my life wishing better games had.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s