It’s been four years since I last wrote anything here. When I had That One Thing(tm) happen to me in late 2022, I put it on Google Docs and linked to it on Twitter. I think that’s because it was extremely depressing and personal and I thought I’d delete it eventually, which I did. What I’ve got to say today is also tied to recent depression but isn’t as bad and might even include some useful advice for people, so I intend to keep it up in perpetuity. Well, until the heat death of the universe, that is.
Do you lie to your friends? The answer is almost certainly “yes,” though you may not realize it. I espoused upon a similar line of thinking in a thread on Bluesky, specifically this part, and I’m expanding upon it here because, truthfully, that part was the entire reason I wrote the post, based on my recent and not-so-recent experience.
There are two types of lies you tell your friends, which I refer to as the “hard” and “soft” lies. The “hard” lies are easy to identify. Someone asks if you want to do something, and you tell them “yes, but later.” The reason you lie is because you don’t want that person to feel bad that you’re rejecting them, but you have zero interest in the thing they’re suggesting. You’re not going to do that thing, no matter what. You know you’re deceiving them, and maybe you feel bad, or maybe you don’t. What’s almost certain is that you hope the other person will forget about it and you won’t be placed in an uncomfortable situation down the road.
The “soft” lie looks similar at first glance. Your friend asks you to do something, and you say “yes, but later.” In this case, though, you actually like what they’re suggesting, and it’s a thing you honestly want to do. You just don’t want to do it right now, so you add it to “the list” of things you’ll get to. Eventually. Someday. Really, you will.
The insidious thing about the soft lie is that you’re not only lying to your friend — albeit unintentionally — but also to yourself.
We all have a limited amount of spare time in the day, after we’ve done all the things we need to do (eat, sleep, make a living, take care of pets/kids/plants/etc.). We all tend to fill that spare time (and beyond, who needs sleep?) with leisure activities, and they generally have a priority rank, based on what you like to do. You like Activity A more than you like Activity B, which you like more than Activity C, so your preference for your spare time is A-B-C.
Then, along comes your friend, wanting to do Activity D. You like Activity D! But you like A, B, and C better, so you add D to the bottom of your priority list. You’re not lying about wanting do to D — it will just come when A, B, and C no longer interest you. Whenever that is …
Like your Steam backlog full of games you really want to play … just after one more match of your favorite shooter or after you’ve finished that long RPG … D takes a back seat to everything else until you can “get around to it.” Which you will, certainly, someday. Oh hey, there’s Activity E, that looks fun …
As I said in the Bluesky thread, that’s not so bad when you’re talking about solo activities, like games on your backlist, books you haven’t read, and so on. It’s less good when another person is waiting for you to finally get around to the activity you promised to do with them. Maybe it’s not a hard promise, and it certainly isn’t a commitment on par with something like marriage, but it can still sting to have those expectations be pushed aside. Sure, it’s a trivial thing you want to do, but it still matters to you — and, by all appearances, doesn’t matter to the other person. When it happens over and over again, you will eventually view your friend as unreliable and unwilling to believe them when they say you want to do something with you “later.”
Thelma & Louise
This was the situation I found myself in earlier this year. I had two friends, both female (neither romantic, FYI), whom I’ll call Thelma and Louise. We met on an RP server and hung out a lot online, played games, watched movies, and so on, over nearly two years. The three of us even had a private Discord chat that one of them titled “The Three Best Friends.” They had known each other before I met on the RP server so I’ll admit to having felt a little like a “third wheel” at times, but overall I felt like I was a part of their little group.
But something I noticed fairly early on was how they were habitual liars — soft liars mostly, though Thelma dove into hard lies later into our time together. It wasn’t a sudden transition. Here’s a Tweet of hers from 2020:

That’s pretty much the essence of the “hard lie” and is, in my opinion, truly abhorrent behavior. Some people have a hard time saying “no,” and a lot of the time I think she was truly sorry she couldn’t find the time to hang out with me and Louise. Seeing this, however, made me re-evaluate all of those instances and wonder if she had ever really been telling the truth.
Louise, on the other hand, did spend a lot of time with me, both with and without Thelma. Her issue was that she was a world-class “soft liar,” and the sad thing is, I don’t think she even realized it (despite my passive-aggressiveness). Around the 2023 Holiday season, we started two long-term games, at her suggestion, playing two sessions each and even keeping notes about what we would do next. She also bought two games, one I already had and one I bought, with the intent that we would play them together. We never did, nor did we play the other two games we started, despite my repeatedly suggesting them. She also made an extensive list of games around the start of that year that she wanted to play, but always refused when I asked if she wanted to try one of them.
She got me back into playing Guild Wars 2 regularly around mid-2024. A few months later, the next expansion dropped, and she dove into the first zone immediately. I needed a little while to catch up with the story, and she told me she really wanted to run the second zone with me. A week later, I was caught up, but she was going through some personal issues, so I waited… and waited… and waited… and when I thought she was in the clear, I asked her if she wanted to try the new zone. She told me she was done with the game, full stop. After that point, I pretty much only asked her to play the one game we had played regularly throughout our time together. I didn’t put much stock in her claims of wanting to do something else unless it was immediate.
Overall, the suggestions I made to both Thelma and Louise were typically things they had expressed interest in, and not just random ideas I came up with. I didn’t mind so much when the latter were refused, but when things on their “lists” didn’t garner much of a response, it became endlessly frustrating.
On the other hand, when a new person joined our Discord server, she immediately captured their attention and interest, suggesting all sorts of activities that they instantly joined. Louise mostly checked out of the one game we did play together regularly, and the private chat the three of us used dwindled to practically nothing. I made the best of it, trying the things they were doing with their new friend, even though I didn’t enjoy them that much. So I made one final attempt to explain my discontent to Thelma. Her response was harsh and insulting, so I bowed out without a response.
Thelma insisted she didn’t have extensive time to game, right up until the end. The day we “unfriended,” I looked at her Steam profile and saw she had 60 hours played over the previous two weeks, or about 4.5 hours per day, in addition to time spent playing non-Steam games. She had plenty of time, just not for what I wanted to do.
I was going through a few other things at that time, and I really needed my friends to step up and show me I was still valued. Instead I got silence or gaslighting when I tried to go into deeper detail about what was making me feel this way. I wanted a conversation but I only got told I was wrong, when I was told anything at all.
Was I a little too clingy? Possibly. Too demanding? Perhaps. Could I have handled things better? Almost certainly. Do I have a paralyzing fear regarding my ability to make and keep friends, always wondering when they’ll abandon me once they’ve found someone or something more interesting to devote their time to, that I’ll no longer be invited to partake of activities we used to enjoy together regularly, and that our time together will steadily wind down until it comes to a complete stop, a pattern that’s repeated itself multiple times in my personal history? Oh, you betcha.
This doesn’t mean people always need to do what I want. I’m totally fine with doing what other people want (perhaps too fine), but I’d like to decide at least some of the time. Otherwise, the “soft lies” add up and eventually I’ll just come to believe that my needs and desires aren’t important to you any more.
To wrap up: “Maybe later” is, at this point in my life, about as offensive a pair of words you can say to me. You-know-who from 2022 lived by those words, or their equivalents, and I’ve heard it countless times from other people over several decades, relating to a wide range of activities. If you get nothing else from reading all this, just know that you shouldn’t use those words around me.
The Better Approach
One thing Louise did right in the final days was when she explained to me that she didn’t want to stream or RP any more because it was too stressful. She had been a fairly regular streamer before I met her. In our time together, she got new graphics made for her channel and was accepted to three RP servers (two of which we intended to play together, along with Thelma), so she clearly wanted to, which is why I frequently asked her if she’d want to hop into an RP server or do a co-stream. It was a classic “soft” lie.
But in declaring that she wasn’t going to do either any more, she had finally removed something from her list, giving up on a soft lie that she was telling herself and others.
That’s how you handle this kind of backlog in your life, whether it’s related to games or some other activity. In the past, I’ve sometimes written out my desires on a sheet of paper and then triaged each of them, putting them in one of three categories:
- I will do this immediately or very, very soon (like, this week)
- I will do this in the near future. Here’s the plan for doing it, and what I’ll need to accomplish it.
- I will not do this, and I will cross it off my list for the foreseeable future.
Number 1 is easy to understand. Number 2 is better than the ambiguous “maybe later,” in that it outlines a course of action rather than just being stuffed onto the back end of a list. It’s OK to say “later,” just as long as you have a concept of when that “later” is — next week, next month, after I finish this other thing, etc. Just make sure you have the capacity to do what you need to in order to get to the thing you want to do. (I hope that made sense.)
Number 3 is probably the hardest for people to come to terms with, but at some point you just have to realize that it isn’t going to happen, whatever “it” is. Once you’ve done that, you can move on and focus better on the things you can do. I’m not the religious sort, but it’s almost an adaptation of the famous Serenity Prayer:

Accept that you cannot do the things you list at #3 and have the wisdom to know that you cannot change that. That time isn’t going to magically appear and it’s better if you just move on.
(I had originally typed “forever” instead of “for the foreseeable future” there, but I can see some reason to think you absolutely can’t do something in the short term but might want to revisit it later if things change drastically later. For instance, you might want to buy a house but know that you can’t afford to right now, and there’s no reason to think that will change. If that’s the case, there’s no point in keeping it on your “list” for now but if some good fortune comes your way later, it might be something you can put back on it. That’s different from #2 because, in this case, you don’t really have control over the circumstances or can see a way that they’ll become favorable.)
There’s the right way and the wrong way to let a friend know you aren’t interested in their activity. The wrong way is to say you can’t because of issues outside of your control (unless that truly is the case); the right way is to let them know it’s simply not something you want to do — perhaps not now, perhaps never. If your friendship is strong enough, it should survive that, provided you at least sometimes do what the other person wants. Continually leading someone on with “I’d love to but I can’t/won’t right now” is a delaying tactic that will only lead to getting asked again and again until you admit the reality of the situation, which will only make things worse.
Tell the truth to your friends. Don’t lie to them, or yourself.










































